TABLE 1

Breast Imaging Devices

Manufacturer
ParameterDilonDilonGammaMedicaDigiradGE HealthcareNaviscan
Model68006800 AcellaLumaGemErgoDiscovery NM 530cHigh-resolution organ-specific PET scanner
No. of heads11211 or 22
Detector materialNaI(Tl)CsI(Tl)CZTCsI(Tl)CZTLutetium yttrium oxyorthosilicate
Detector size3 × 3 × 6 mm3 × 3 × 6 mm1.6 × 1.6 × 5 mm3 × 3 × 6 mm2.6 × 2.6 mm2 × 2 × 13 mm
Photon/electron collectionPSPMTp-type/intrinsic/n-type photodiodeApplication-specific integrated circuitSilicon photodiodeApplication-specific integrated circuitPSPMT
Collimationγ-camera typesγ-camera typesRegistered collimatorγ-camera types, pinholeRegistered collimatorNone
Dead space10 mm10 mm8 mm12.7 mm“Minimal”13 mm
Imaging FOV15 × 20 cm20 × 25 cm16 × 20 cm40 × 30 cm16 × 24 cm17 × 24 cm
Energy resolution13.5%7.9%<5% (140 keV)7.9% (140 keV)6.5% (140 keV)13%
Energy range70–200 keV50–170 keVOptimized for photons < 160 keV, capable of up to 511 keV50–350 keV80–200 keV350–700 keV
Spatial resolution3.3 mm3.3 mm1.6 mm3.3 mm2.46 mm2.4 mm
Source for statisticsCompany’s specification sheetCompany’s specification sheetCompany’s specification sheet and written communication from James Hugg, Chief Technology Officer, GammaMedica, August 2011Company’s specification sheetCompany’s specification sheetLuo and MacDonald articles and written communication from Weidong Luo, Director of Imaging Physics for Naviscan, October 2011